In this episode of On Boards, Joe Ayoub and Raza Shaikh speak with Shefaly Yogendra, an independent non-executive director and author of “Uncharted Spaces: Reset the Agenda. Reimagine the Boardroom.” In this episode, Shefaly discusses how boards can move beyond traditional governance practices to prepare for an increasingly uncertain future.
Shefaly highlights why boards need to rethink their agendas, decision-making, and meeting practices and board composition to encourage more meaningful discussions. She also explores the importance of “cognitive diversity” and the role of board chairs in drawing out different perspectives from members, and how more thoughtful director recruitment can help build stronger, more effective boards.
Key takeaways
- Boards need to spend more time looking forward rather than reviewing the past
- Research suggests boards spend between 40% and 70% of their time reviewing past performance, creating a backward-looking approach
- Geopolitics, technology and climate change are increasingly interconnected, requiring boards to anticipate risks and opportunities rather than rely on historical information
- Boards must rethink what they pay attention to, how they evaluate information and how they distinguish facts from assumptions when making decisions
- Meaningful board discussions require intentional meeting practices and effective leadership
- Board effectiveness depends on four factors: the agenda, the people around the table, the frequency of meetings and the culture that encourages open discussion
- Chairs should understand each director’s strengths, perspectives and communication styles to create opportunities for everyone to contribute
- Directors should periodically evaluate meeting effectiveness, including whether the right topics were discussed and whether the board made meaningful progress
- Clearly identifying whether board materials are for information, approval or debate can help prioritize discussions and make better use of meeting time
- Cognitive diversity must be actively encouraged
- Traditional approaches to diversity often rely on visible characteristics such as gender, race and ethnicity without examining the different perspectives individuals bring
- Cognitive diversity comes from a combination of education, professional experience, lived experiences, decision-making approaches and individual perspectives
- A board chair plays an important role in eliciting these perspectives and creating an environment where directors feel comfortable challenging assumptions
- Board skills matrices should be living documents, regularly reviewed to identify emerging needs, including different risk personalities, temperaments and crisis-management capabilities
- Effective board recruitment requires deeper evaluation of candidates
- Short recruitment processes can make it difficult to understand what unique perspectives and capabilities a candidate would bring to a board
- Boards should evaluate candidates based on how their experiences and ways of thinking address the organization’s strategic needs, rather than relying primarily on traditional qualifications or visible diversity markers
- Recruiters should conduct thorough background checks and provide meaningful candidate assessments that help boards understand what it would be like to work with someone
- Strong recruiters must be willing to offer independent judgment, including raising concerns when a candidate may not be the right fit
Quotes
“Compliance and reporting are necessary elements, but they can also risk becoming a fig leaf for boards that are not brave enough to look forward to seeing what is ahead and what’s around them.”
“The idea of cognitive diversity isn’t to add and stir, but to elicit.”
Links
Uncharted Spaces: Reset the agenda. Reimagine the boardroom.
Guest bio
Shefaly Yogendra, PhD is an experienced independent board director with a decade of experience on boards of Owner-led as well as Professional Manager-led organisations. Shefaly enables enhanced resilience and value creation on her boards with the lenses of technology and innovation, risk and strategic foresight, and good governance practice.
Shefaly’s board experience in regulated sectors includes financial services, energy, higher education and legal services, and encompasses several capital events including an IPO on the LSE, a merger, an acquisition and debt financings as well as leading through organisational crises and challenges. Shefaly is an experienced committee chair having chaired Audit & Risk, Nomination, Remuneration, and ESG.
Her book “Uncharted Spaces. Reset the Agenda. Reimagine the Boardroom.” Was published in April 2026 and is catalysing critical conversations amongst Chairs, boards and their advisers.
Transcript:
Joe Ayoub (00:06)
Welcome to On Boards. I’m Joe Ayoub, and I’m here with my co-host Raza Shaikh. Twice a month, we explore what makes a board a strategic asset for any company or organization, as well as the important issues that are facing boards, company leadership, and stakeholders. Today we’re joined by Shefaly Yugendra to talk about the central challenge of her new book, ”Uncharted Spaces.”
How boards can move beyond governance models built for the past and become better prepared to anticipate change and help their organization to succeed in an uncertain future.
Before we introduce our guest, we want to acknowledge our sponsors.
First, we’d like to thank our longtime sponsor, the law firm of Nutter, McClellan and Fish, who again is sponsoring both our On Board Summit this year in October, and our podcast. With offices in Boston, New York, and San Francisco, Nutter serves as trusted counselor to a wide range of public, private, and nonprofit organizations, as well as investors and boards, helping them build, grow, and govern through every stage of their development.
And we’re proud to welcome PWC Private as a sponsor of our summit and our podcast. For 25 years, PWC Private has focused exclusively on helping private companies, owners, and boards navigate complexity, make informed decisions, and prepare for what’s next.
Shefaly is an experienced independent non executive director and committee chair. She has served on boards of both listed and privately held companies and currently serves on the board of the Temple Bar Investment Trust and UK based AMPA Group LLP.
Raza S (02:08)
She brings over three decades of multi-sector experience and multidisciplinary training in questions of technology and innovation, risk and foresight, and governance practices.
Joe Ayoub (02:20)
And as I mentioned, she is the author of “Uncharted Spaces. Reset the agenda. Reimagined the boardroom,” published in April 2026. Shefaly, welcome to On Boards. It’s terrific to have you with us today.
Shefaly Yogendra (02:36)
Thank you for having me. It’s brilliant to be here.
Joe Ayoub (02:38)
Your book is called “Uncharted Spaces. Reset the Agenda, Reimagine the Boardroom.” What are the uncharted spaces that boards are failing to explore today? And why do you think that so many boards still govern for the world as it was rather than the future that is emerging?
Shefaly Yogendra (03:00)
That’s a really cracking question, Various pieces of research about board behaviors that emerge from time to time suggest that boards, too many boards, actually spend between 40 to 70 % of their time in reviewing past performance.
That’s essentially a rear view mirror exercise, a backward-looking board meeting. Compliance and reporting, as we know, is necessary. They are necessary elements but they can also risk becoming a fig leaf for boards that are not brave enough to look forward to see what is ahead and what’s around them.
Joe Ayoub (03:39)
So they’re just trying to fill the time in some ways?
Shefaly Yogendra (03:42)
And the uncharted spaces today are about navigating a complex set of issues in geopolitics, technology, climate change, all kind of interplaying with one another, creating risks as well as opportunities in ways that demand imagination in addition to bravery. So to your question, why do so many boards try to govern for the world as it was, well, it’s comfortable and it’s comforting.
Joe Ayoub (04:10)
Mm, yeah.
Shefaly Yogendra (04:11)
And the macro context is changing, but it is also made harder by the sheer deluge of information. And then there is technology mediated echo chambers.
And then there are demands to make data back decisions for the long term, and the short term is changing several times a day. So I would say that this new information environment that we are operating in demands new ways of what I call epistemic navigation, which is basically how we learn to pay attention. What do we pay attention to? How do we evaluate the claims made by data? How do we discern truth from half truths? And how do we establish the basis for meaningful action? So I know that the way I have described it probably makes people feel a bit sick in the stomach, right?
Joe Ayoub (05:07)
Hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (05:08)
But let’s now try and spare a thought for board directors who have to navigate this every day in order to make meaningful decisions. So given all of that, I think it’s comfortable and it’s comforting to seek refuge in the past, in past performance. I mean, after all, board directors are human. It’s perfectly human.
Raza S (05:28)
Shefaly, as you mentioned that maybe only 30 % to a little more time is spent in actual discussions. Why do many boards struggle on the discussion part to generate meaningful discussion during board meetings?
Shefaly Yogendra (05:43)
I think if you were to discuss this with sort of broad bullet point kind of answers, I would say the agenda is often wrong, as in we are focusing on the wrong topics, wrong things, wrong subjects, wrong amount of depth. The people around the table could be wrong. They may not be the people who are going to serve the company as it faces the future. And then the cadence could be wrong.
As we know, a lot of boards just meet four to six times a year. When things are changing almost on a daily, weekly, monthly basis, boards have to question how do they actually operate? What is the rhythm of their operation? And then finally, there could be the wrong kind of culture. Maybe there is a board that entertains the idea of let’s just discuss what’s in the board pack, just like agree on everything and go home. And there’s some boards that want to go a bit further, but they have to then provide the conditions for the debate and the conversation to happen.
So when all four things come together, what are you discussing, with whom, how frequently, and do you really provide the conditions for the conversation to emerge when all four prior factors are present? Then the discussion would be meaningful, I imagine.
Raza S (07:02)
I think what struck me the most is the point that you made about agenda construction itself. That’s half the battle.
And what other meeting practices should boards adopt to address this discussion issue? And what are practical, tactical things to try to bring in?
Shefaly Yogendra (07:22)
So, drawing on my experience, as well as the conversations I had with lots of directors around the world in the process of writing my book, one of the things that was a recurrent theme is that a board must honestly and periodically reflect on their own effectiveness as well as their own relevance. So sometimes, you know, I know that there’s a big difference between the US and the UK that the US doesn’t have term limits.
For us on, particularly on listed boards, we have a term limit of maximum of nine years. And that is
Joe Ayoub (07:57)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (07:58)
essentially to prevent people becoming fittings and fixtures on their boards.
Joe Ayoub (08:02)
I just want to interrupt for a minute. That is a huge difference.
Shefaly Yogendra (08:05)
That’s a massive difference, yes.
Raza S (08:07)
Mm-hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (08:07)
And it directly relates to the idea of relevance. Somebody may bring a lot of in-depth knowledge, let’s say of an industry, while the boundaries of that industry are dissolving or being blown up altogether because of the way technology is disintermediating certain players. How will that person or those professionals remain relevant on the board? So there two elements, I would say, relevance and effectiveness.
And a good practice, and it’s not a massively demanding practice, is at the end of every meeting, we could review, how did the meeting go today? Did we discuss everything we met to discuss?
Did we have enough time? What did we not have enough time for? Should we curtail the time given to certain topics and bring other things onto the agenda? But also, did we really talk about what moved us forward?
One of the chairman I have quoted in the book actually said everybody must feel that we all made a contribution and we made progress, forward progress for the company. That’s kind of like the test of the value of a board meeting.
Raza S (09:19)
And I think that part of, uh let’s say the chair or lead director uh in an executive session needs to have these uh techniques. example, if you just simply said, hey, anybody has anything, know, casually, you don’t really prompt well people’s thoughts to bring out. So it’s kind of part of the job of the chair and the lead director who’s organizing the discussion literally in a board meeting to be able to prompt in slightly different ways so that you can get output and discussion and enable that a lot more.
Shefaly Yogendra (09:58)
Yes.
Joe Ayoub (09:58)
Yeah, in a way, the other way is almost a lazy way to solicit. You have to be more thoughtful about what is it you want from your board. Um that’s uh yet one of the many things that a chair is responsible for. I’m curious before we go to the next question, would the adoption of a consent agenda also help eliminate some of the time that’s spent on stuff that is kind of routine, even though it’s you have to discuss it and you have to approve it.
What are your thoughts about that?
Shefaly Yogendra (10:29)
think we use sometimes different terminology from the US over here. And essentially, a board pack, think it should say upfront, is this for information? Is this for approval? Is this for debate? Is this just an update with no earth-shattering findings for the board to consider?
Joe Ayoub (10:48)
Right. Yep.
Shefaly Yogendra (10:50)
And if that is stated upfront at the top of the board pack, then the person who’s reading the board pack, a board director, essentially understands what they’re reading it for. Now that is not to say that if something is for information, we can’t raise questions. But in terms of prioritization, we could say, well, that means those questions can go to the exec because part of the job is to support them. We are not there to do like a gotcha on executive teams.
Joe Ayoub (11:17)
Right.
Shefaly Yogendra (11:18)
We could send them questions offline and say, could you provide more information on this?
And that allows us to use our judgment while we reading the board pack as well. And as you know, most of the board packs are now distributed digitally. And there are
Raza S (11:32)
Mm-hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (11:32)
features in pretty much every board software to make annotations and decide who you’re going to share them with. And you can then say, OK, these are my own annotations. These are annotations I want to share with the board. Or these are questions I want to share with the exec team.
So the tools that are available also make it easy. You don’t have to generate a ton of email traffic just to elicit further additional information from the team. But that clarity of what do want me to do with this paper needs to be established upfront. And I think that kind of board pack hygiene practices can always get better.
Joe Ayoub (12:08)
Yeah. Don’t just send out four hundred pages and expect everyone to, you know, understand exactly what you want. I think that that’s brilliant. Well, that kinda leads to the next question. You know, when we spoke recently, one of the things you said was governance is a context board, which really caught my attention. I and I I I get what you mean. and that board effectiveness requires practice.
Tell me what you mean by practice in in reality. What what should boards do to make sure they’re practicing?
Shefaly Yogendra (12:43)
That’s actually a good way to segue into something that both you and I are interested in, Joe, and that is yoga. And you might think
Joe Ayoub (12:51)
Yeah.
Shefaly Yogendra (12:52)
your listeners are already thinking, where is this going? Essentially, we call it a yoga practice, the half
Joe Ayoub (12:58)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (12:59)
an hour, one hour that we devote every day. And we notice that day to day, our practice varies based on how we are feeling in our mind, how we are feeling in our body, how do we feel a sense of balance.
And the same pose is maybe tough or easy given the day, right? And in a similar way from board meeting to board meeting, we perform differently. And the difference is the reflection. What have I done today that is worth carrying
Joe Ayoub (13:27)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (13:28)
with me to the next board meeting? And what is it that I can leave behind? And we have all been in so many board meetings when we come away saying, shouldn’t have said that, shouldn’t have said that in that tone, or should have interpreted it or shouldn’t remember to make that point. So the process of reflecting in the practice on what we are doing, being very mindfully present there to say, I make a little corrective right now?
And then after the meeting, whether with the board or after the board, continuing to reflect on how did I contribute? Did I contribute meaningfully? What can I improve about my own way of engaging, my own way of eliciting value from my other board colleagues?
And my own way of regulating myself sometimes. Am I talking too long?
Am I not talking enough? That kind of stuff. But the reason why I call it a contact sport is we have to respond in the moment. We can’t prepare, for example, 20 points. These are 20 points I’m going to make. If others make 16 out of those 20 points, I don’t have to repeat them just so that I can get class participation grade.
Raza S (14:37)
Hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (14:37)
And I think knowing that difference and being able to self-regulate and self-correct and then reflect afterwards to bring out the best of oneself to contribute meaningfully in the next board meeting. That’s why I refer to it as contact support.
Joe Ayoub (14:54)
Thank you. That’s terrific.
Raza S (14:55)
Shefaly, we’ve talked earlier about the role of the chair and the important role that the chair plays for making it a high performing board. If a board chair is listening to this conversation and they recognize that their board needs to change, but not are in the position to replace half of the directors or redesign the whole governance structure right at that moment.
What are three or four things they could do maybe even at the next board meeting to begin creating the kind of board, the kind of effective board that you envision?
Shefaly Yogendra (15:32)
I think of the board chair as like the orchestra conductor or even the captain of the Starship Enterprise. And
Raza S (15:39)
Hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (15:40)
neither of these two characters would go into their concert or even places where no man or woman has gone before without some preparation. And drawing upon some of my own experience and having witnessed good chairing and practices from good chairs.
I would say some things a chair listening to our conversation today could do. One is they have to know every board director around the table well. And I don’t mean just their name. I want each chair to be able to say, this is this person’s particular additive lens to our board. they’re
Joe Ayoub (16:20)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (16:20)
ready to add. What is their style of engagement? And where to bring them into the sequence in the conversation, for instance, to elicit their opinion. So for instance, if you have people who are experts, they often have very definitive opinions that can completely shut down anybody who’s about to ask a question, because then they
Raza S (16:41)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (16:41)
don’t want to look stupid. But this means that a lot of times, questions that could put more color around the conversation may not get asked. So you let the expert speak last, not first.
Similarly, there might be introverts who would be grateful to the chairman for not being called first. They may want some time to gather their idea and then talk about it. So knowing each board director around the table well. The second thing I would say a lot of, as we know, good boards do a lot of work outside the board meetings, the formal board meetings. And drawing on uh my own experience as nomination chair on one of my boards and audit and risk chair from one of my past boards,
I think taking soundings from every director outside the board meeting, particularly before board meeting, really helps. And what I found is that people will say things to you and say, I want to say it, but I don’t want to say it.
Joe Ayoub (17:41)
Yeah.
Shefaly Yogendra (17:42)
So the chair can then be aware that these points want to be surfaced, including contentious ones or difficult ones. But then the chair is then equipped to run the flow of the conversation.
At the same time, they can also lend their shoulder to the contentious point to say, well, what about this? And they can be seen to say the difficult bit sometimes, which people have already told them about. I also feel that this helps surface the questions, as I was saying earlier, to be sent to the exec if there is a more detailed answer to be obtained. And that is something that can come out of these questions. And there is, you know, the added benefit that these conversations will ensure that all the directors have actually read the board pack before they talk to the chairman. Because this is,
Raza S (18:29)
Mm-hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (18:31)
as you know, it’s a contention, right? Sometimes people don’t read the board pack. So if you’re going to discuss
Joe Ayoub (18:35)
Absolutely.
Shefaly Yogendra (18:36)
it with the chair before the meeting, you will read the board pack.
Joe Ayoub (18:39)
Great idea.
Raza S (18:42)
All of these ideas really resonate. In fact, I was thinking, I heard a similar thing from my friend who ran the endowment Princeton, that they would have the most junior person actually speak first and the more experienced folks
Joe Ayoub (18:59)
Ruh.
Raza S (19:00)
to speak later, not only to make them comfortable, to also say that their opinion and thought also matters and we want to take that in first.
Shefaly Yogendra (19:08)
Yes. Yes.
Yes.
Joe Ayoub (19:11)
Yeah. Assuring that you’re gonna hear everyone’s voice is a
Shefaly Yogendra (19:15)
Mm-hmm.
Joe Ayoub (19:15)
great if a chair can achieve that, then that’s a that’s a huge thing. Um I’d like to talk about a subject that is very near and dear to my heart, which is building and maintaining truly excellent boards. Um as you know, my my lawyer day my trial lawyer days are over and I’ve been a board recruiter for the last 15 years. And I
Raza and I have talked a lot about the importance of having what we call a diversity of perspective in the boardroom. You’ve used the term cognitive diversity. What does that look like around a boardroom? And why do you think it’s difficult to recruit for that?
Shefaly Yogendra (19:58)
So if you’d indulge me, Joe, I’ll address the second part first. And I think it’s difficult to recruit for because the process of bringing a new director, recruiting a new director onto the board can be too short and often not very effective at assessing cognitive diversity. We’ll come to the, I’m big on definitions, so we’ll come to that kind of stuff in a minute.
Joe Ayoub (20:21)
if there were a better process, then it would be easier to find those people who constitute cognitive diversity in a boardroom.
Shefaly Yogendra (20:32)
I’m saying something slightly adjacent but related. What I’m saying is
Joe Ayoub (20:35)
Okay.
Shefaly Yogendra (20:36)
I think each one of us can bring cognitive diversity, but somebody before they appoint us to a board has to know what that is. What is that value addition that we are bringing, right? And the process being quite short and curtailed can stand in the way of figuring out what is it that this person is really bringing.
And at the same time, in a sidebar, I would mention there is a growing conversation this side in the UK about should we use psychometrics in assessing board directors. And I’m thinking, you know our entire job as board directors is amorphous and unstructured. And we are trying
Joe Ayoub (21:15)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (21:16)
to lean on some very definitive sounding answers from tools that are not inherently perfect. They may be, in fact, inherently flawed and which tool will you choose? So that’s a whole different kind of conversation, right?
But then there is not a great deal of uniformity in the understanding of what the term cognitive diversity means. So if I might unpack my own stack of how I approach things, studying engineering taught me how to define problems full-simly. You don’t start solving what you haven’t defined first, right?
And then when I studied management, it taught me, well, we don’t have infinite amounts of money, time, human resource, attention, et cetera. And then studying policy alerted me that in organizations where even resources might be in plenty, power and politics will determine what really gets on the agenda, what gets discussed, and eventually what decisions may get chosen over what look like better decisions. So then I went and did some doctoral work in decision making, which means I went and read a ton of literature about how human beings actually make decisions and what do we know about all of it.
Now, all of this has given me a very rich toolkit. But with the exception of one board hiding interview, I have actually never been asked a question to crystallize how all of this plus my lived experience and now increasingly my board experience and my prior experience in advisory and executive roles would actually help me add value to that particular board. So what happens when people don’t…
Joe Ayoub (22:55)
Hm. Never? You’ve never been asked.
Shefaly Yogendra (22:59)
Yeah, so when you don’t elicit this part in the process, what ends up happening is one, that people end up using gender, race, ethnicity, et cetera, as markers of diversity, which is not very effective in my view.
Joe Ayoub (23:14)
Agreed.
Shefaly Yogendra (23:14)
And the second thing that can happen is they just give up and hire people who do not make them nervous, which means we all end up either with tokenism or uniformity. So the process of discovering candidates, assessing candidates, and then giving them a chance in the conversation, not just for that ephemeral chemistry check, but to actually give them a chance to articulate how are they going to be adding value to the board, which then puts the pressure on the person putting themselves forward to have done the work to look at the board and say, this is what the company does.
This is what it’s needing strategically. This is what this board has, and this is my additional value.
Joe Ayoub (23:59)
Yeah, that’s unrealistic. I it is unrealistic to put all of the burden and and and probably ineffective is what you’re really saying on the burden of the candidates. Some candidates will do it, but not everyone is gonna figure this out. So I I just want to follow up with two questions, a two-part.
Shefaly Yogendra (24:17)
Mm-hmm. oh
Joe Ayoub (24:19)
A lot what you’ve to summarize, I’ve just said a big part of the problem is the the recruitment process, which I wanted I do want to ask you a question about.
But I want to ask a more specific question first. So assuming there is a good process, what is the difference between genuine cognitive diversity that and diversity that may change the composition of the board without really changing the conversation? What is that thing that we’re really looking for? And then I have a follow-up to that.
Shefaly Yogendra (24:55)
Yeah, so I think the value, as I was saying earlier, each of us can bring a different perspective. The value is in the elicitation. If something is just sitting there, it doesn’t matter what it’s worth. It has to be elicited in the context of the conversation or in a particular board meeting or a particular topic. It has to be elicited and that space has to be provided.
So if I might tell you a little story, I had a chairman who had studied in Cambridge. And I asked him in a conversation exactly on this topic. I said, you think I’m a diversity, don’t you? So he
Joe Ayoub (25:37)
Ha ha ha.
Shefaly Yogendra (25:38)
was a little bit shaken. like, what do you mean? So I said, I’ll tell you what I mean. I’ll unpack this. You think I’m different because you’re a tall white man and I’m a not so tall South Asian woman. He said, OK, where is this going? I said,
But remember that you attended Cambridge, so did I. But unlike you, I attended elite institutions on three continents. Almost all of them educated me in the Western liberal tradition. So cognitively, how different do you think I am in training from your training?
Joe Ayoub (26:13)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (26:14)
He said, which means we are the same. I said, we are not the same. We are quite similar. And this is why you will find in a lot of principles of rationality, I agree with you.
I agree with your analysis. I may add a point you have overlooked or not thought of and so on, because I’m educated differently. But at the same time, on top of everything else, you live in a country where you were born. I am an immigrant. I’m a woman of color navigating a country that’s predominantly white, and I’m navigating it as an immigrant. And I’m navigating the world as a woman when we know the default design was for a man.
So I bring perspectives from that lived experience where I will say certain things which may surprise you, but if you allow me to say those things, you will see the perspective of someone who’s not like you. And
Joe Ayoub (27:04)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (27:04)
that’s why I’m saying that the idea of cognitive diversity isn’t to add and stir, but to elicit.
And that elicitation is the job, as we were discussing earlier, of a good chair.
Raza S (27:18)
Shefali, does it also then mean that the goal of what uh roles you need to fill needs to be tied back to the board skill matrix and this concept of cognitive diversity also somehow has to be brought into that matrix itself?
Shefaly Yogendra (27:41)
Yes, I think the skills matrix is I feel an underutilized asset.
Joe Ayoub (27:49)
Yes.
Shefaly Yogendra (27:50)
It really needs to be not a one and done thing, but like an organic living document, which at every annual board evaluation could be looked at to say, right, this is what we had and it worked for us in the following ways in the preceding year. But for the forward year, we need these extra skills. Are we going to bring a person for this extra skill or are we going to fill that gap through advisory input or some kind of a training mechanism? So we identify our need. For instance, this conversation is quite live around technology. How many technologists can you stuff on a board? And how big will that board be and where are you going to hold the meeting? Essentially to accommodate everyone, right?
So I think being able to dynamically keep track of what we need and to determine whether we can fill that need only through the appointment of a director or do we essentially also allow some kind of advisory input or some other source of input to come in.
Raza S (28:57)
What I meant more was sort of like what they do in the board skill matrix today is those are functional skills. How many marketing people do we have? How many have finance and accounting and so on? And uh the DCRO, David Koenig uh came up with another uh aspect of evaluation of a board member, which is the risk personality type.
Shefaly Yogendra (29:26)
Mm-hmm.
Raza S (29:26)
And so I was thinking more like you add another column to the matrix and you add what risk personality type we have. That’s a different one dimension of cognitive thinking or something like that. And I was thinking more like maybe we need to add two or three more columns to
Joe Ayoub (29:45)
Yeah.
Shefaly Yogendra (29:45)
Mm-hmm.
Raza S (29:46)
the skill matrix that are not functional skills.
Shefaly Yogendra (29:49)
Hmm. It’s actually,
yeah, so it’s a very good point because when I talk about the construction of the board at different points in the book, in one of the spaces, I do say you probably need a bond villain on your board because that person will be able to think of all the risks, turn them into opportunities and will be resourceful enough to work out what resources are needed to make it happen.
But will therefore be also probably a good value addition in terms of thinking about if someone were thinking adversarially about attacking your company or destroying your business, how would
Raza S (30:26)
Mm-hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (30:27)
they be thinking? So we do need uh people who have different kinds of imaginations, different kinds of temperaments. And then we are reading so much about cyber attacks and all kinds of other calamities.
In every calamity, you don’t need everybody all hands to the till. You need some people to run the AU. You need some
Raza S (30:48)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (30:48)
people to roll up their sleeves and deal with the crisis. And you need some people to actually just be the interlocutors, the intermediaries, the people who translate and communicate to different stakeholders. But being able to know who’s good for what should be a thing that everybody around the table should know. And therefore, after every
you know, assessment, let’s say every annual evaluation or even after a crisis, what is it we were missing and should we add that? So I really love that idea of adding one is what is your risk personality type, but also what are your particular skills? There are some people who are good at crises and some people
Raza S (31:28)
Mm-hmm.
Shefaly Yogendra (31:29)
freeze. It’s nothing to do with them and they’re not terrible people that they freeze,
Raza S (31:33)
Yeah.
Shefaly Yogendra (31:34)
but you don’t need everybody in a crisis, right?
Joe Ayoub (31:37)
Yeah. I I wanna echo your comment earlier about uh the regularity with which a board needs to examine its composition. I’ve used the analogy that um you have a strategic plan, you put it together, you don’t then just put it on the shelf for five years. Every year you have to review it because the company’s changing, the world’s changing, everything’s changing. It’s the same with the board. Everything’s
Shefaly Yogendra (32:00)
Yes.
Joe Ayoub (32:02)
changing. So if you don’t do it regularly,
Then even if you did a very detailed and well thought out, you know, board chart and you don’t review it every year, it doesn’t really matter because you’re looking at the past again. You’re not looking at where we are now or where you’re going. So really well said. So my my last question here is um, I agree with you that a lot of board recruitment is not as thorough and effective as it should be. Um
Other than hiring my company, uh Veruna Strategies, but seriously, what what what should organizations do to make sure they get a thorough and effective board recruiter? Um, other than just saying to whoever they hire, here’s what I want you to do, because if you’re telling the recruiter what you want, you’re probably not with the right person. So how do they deal with that in the real world?
When the overwhelming majority probably are not as thorough as as I think you would expect and hope for and and and and and I think is absolutely necessary.
Shefaly Yogendra (33:15)
I think sometimes, we learn, and just as in life, we learn more from failures and falling on our face than we do with successes. And if one has had bad experiences with board recruiters, one knows absolutely what not to look for. So there are, for instance, recruiters who are very good at background due diligence, and their candidate reports are really, they paint a pen picture. Now, I’m not saying Shakespeare should be writing your candidate reports, but giving
Joe Ayoub (33:46)
Ha ha ha.
Shefaly Yogendra (33:47)
an insight into the candidate and actually checking what is their reputation like, what do people say about
Joe Ayoub (33:54)
Yeah.
Shefaly Yogendra (33:55)
them, people who know them well versus people who don’t know them well, creating a candidate report that gives us some idea of what it will be like to work with this person. And then we do the interview. A lot of times, uh very poor candidate due diligence is where quite a few recruiters basically let the hiring board down. I also think that sometimes instruction can be taken very literally. So if they, for instance, see a board’s only person of color retiring, you get a list that has nobody else but people of color. That’s kind of…
essentializing
Joe Ayoub (34:38)
Yeah yeah.
Shefaly Yogendra (34:39)
something when what we should be doing is normalizing something.
Joe Ayoub (34:43)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (34:44)
And in doing that, they are essentializing the diversity to the externally visible characteristics rather than going into the depth and saying, this is the extra value that they bring. And by the way, in order for you to have X percentage of people who are uh minority origin, this also works.
So I think getting the sequence of the priorities right and understanding that. And a lot of times, it’s like a letter box. You send a letter and it comes out at the other end. There’s no value addition. There needs to be some kind of value addition where they tell us that, you do want to include us. Sometimes people say to a recruiter, can you include that candidate in the long list? It’s fine. But then the headhunter should have the courage to say,
We did do the background checks, and we don’t think they’re a good fit for your board. If you want to interview them, go right ahead with this is our informed opinion. I
Joe Ayoub (35:43)
Mm.
Shefaly Yogendra (35:43)
don’t think many recruiters are willing to say that to a nomination committee chair.
Joe Ayoub (35:48)
I think that’s right. I think that’s right. Shefaly, thank you so much for joining us today on board on onboards. It’s been a terrific conversation. And thank
Shefaly Yogendra (35:58)
Thank you for having me.
Joe Ayoub (35:59)
you all for listening to On Boards today. If you enjoyed the show, follow it and leave a review. We look forward to seeing you on the next episode of On Boards.